“Chopper” the rottweiler

High Court confirms it is the dog owner’s behavior, not the victim’s, that was under scrutiny in serious attack

After a short hearing in the High Court yesterday, Justice Brewer agreed with Jodi Libbey, appearing for Tauranga City Council, that it was the dog owner’s behavior and not the victim’s that was under scrutiny after Chopper the 50kg rottweiler seriously attacked a vet and broke her arm.

In convicting the dog owner and remitting the case back for sentencing, the Judge succinctly said that “[the dog owner] could have taken two simple steps.  She could have kept Chopper in the car.  Or, and this might not have been enough, she could have kept physical control of Chopper herself rather than leaving the dog with her 13 year old son.”

This case has attracted a lot of attention in the past year and provides a useful reminder of the obligations that dog owners have.

For any of council clients interested, the decision of Tauranga City Council v Fraser [2023] NZHC 723 can be downloaded from our website here.

Related news

30 years on – What does the 2025 revamp of the Solicitor-General Prosecution Guidelines mean for local authorities?

30 years on – What does the 2025 revamp of the Solicitor-General Prosecution Guidelines mean for local authorities? Overview The Solicitor-General Prosecution Guidelines are fundamental in shaping Aotearoa’s criminal justice system, and they have recently been updated following the most comprehensive review in over 30 years. While the definition of “prosecuting agency” excludes local authorities,…

Reserves valuations – Trash or Treasure?

For those who have been involved in the process of valuing a reserve, whether for disposal or exchange, you will appreciate the challenge often faced.  How do you value a reserve, whether it be open space for passive recreation or developed with a playground or sports field, that services the community and has been set…

Court rejects ‘total absence of fault’ defence following serious injury to young child

Court rejects ‘total absence of fault’ defence following serious injury to young child Background The defendant’s dog, a male American Pitbull-cross, attacked a young child visiting her property.  The victim suffered serious injuries, including wounds around her eye from a dog bite to the face.  The defendant was charged under s 58 of the Dog…