Guidance for Building Consent Authorities in the wake of Cyclone Gabrielle

Natural hazards at a time of significant uncertainty – guidance for Building Consent Authorities in the wake of Cyclone Gabrielle

Cyclone Gabrielle was one of the largest natural disasters in the history of Aotearoa New Zealand.  Many North Island councils (as well as some South Island ones) have grappled with how to approach building consenting in the wake of this year’s severe weather events.  The applicability of sections 71-74 of the Building Act 2004, which relate to natural hazards, have never been more in focus.

In Te Matau a Māui Hawke’s Bay, the Regional Council undertook risk assessments and categorised flood-affected areas into three broad categories, with category 2 having four subcategories depending on whether further assessment or interventions are required to manage the risks.  In August, there were 723 properties in Hawke’s Bay that fell into categories 2 and 3.

Hawke’s Bay Regional Council has a lot on its plate right now and therefore couldn’t provide Building Consent Authorities with important information needed to assess finished floor levels.  In particular, it remains uncertain what magnitude of an event Cyclone Gabrielle was, what new finished floor levels need to be, whether the effects and impacts of climate change will be considered as part of the repair of stop banks and many other big questions.

Rice Speir has worked collaboratively with Hawke’s Bay councils to create a guidance document, specifically designed for consenting residential buildings or sleeping accommodation while the above key information about Cyclone Gabrielle remains uncertain.  The Guidance Document sets out how affected councils will apply the natural hazard provisions of the Act in the categorised areas.

Key stakeholders including HBRC and MBIE were consulted and provided helpful feedback throughout the process and a retired High Court Judge deemed the Guidance Document to be “an elegant solution to a difficult problem”.

Working with Hawke’s Bay councils has been a particularly rewarding experience and we know the guidance will be put to use promptly so that people can get back into their homes safely.

The Guidance Document can be found here; and following its release MBIE issued its own guidance on sections 71 to 74 of the Act, which can be viewed on their website here.

Related news

Not above the law: options when faced with a sovereign citizen

As local councils across New Zealand carry out their statutory duties under the Building Act 2004, a growing challenge has emerged in the form of “sovereign citizens.” These individuals typically attempt to deny the legitimacy of government authority and may attempt to frustrate compliance processes—including by refusing entry to property, rejecting compliance action, or disputing…

Natural Hazard Information: what’s changing for LIMs in 2025

Natural hazards are a topical issue, and big changes are on the horizon for how hazard information is communicated in Land Information Memoranda (LIMs). From 1 July 2025, the Local Government Official Information and Meetings Amendment Act 2023 (LGOIMA) will come into force, introducing changes to the LIM provisions that are specifically tailored to the…

Three-day inspection mandate: well intentioned, but is it well thought out?

In a move designed to improve efficiency and reduce delays in construction projects nationwide, the government has announced a significant new requirement for Building Consent Authorities (BCAs).  Intended to commence from late 2025, BCAs will be required to complete 80 percent of building inspections within three working days of the request. The Government aims to…

30 years on – Solicitor-General Prosecution Guidelines revamp

30 years on – What does the 2025 revamp of the Solicitor-General Prosecution Guidelines mean for local authorities? Overview The Solicitor-General Prosecution Guidelines are fundamental in shaping Aotearoa’s criminal justice system, and they have recently been updated following the most comprehensive review in over 30 years. While the definition of “prosecuting agency” excludes local authorities,…