ChatGPT: a helpful tool or legal roulette?

As a tech-savvy lawyer, I’m always on the lookout for new tools to make my job easier. But let me tell you, there’s one tool that’s been causing me a lot of trouble lately – ChatGPT.

ChatGPT is an AI language model that can help lawyers find and present legal authorities quickly, but there’s a major hangup – it’s not always accurate. In fact, it’s been known to give some pretty wacky and downright wrong information. I mean, we’re talking about a tool that can give you a citation to a case that doesn’t exist, or reference the wrong section of an act, and provide links to websites that have nothing to do with the authority it references. It’s like playing a game of legal roulette, and we’re not always sure if we’re going to hit the jackpot or come up empty-handed.

In addition to these errors ChatGPT can make other mistakes. For example, it can provide outdated or irrelevant information.  It may also misunderstand the context of the question or inquiry and provide a response that while technically correct, is not useful or applicable to the specific legal issue at hand.

While ChatGPT is a whizz at spitting out information, let’s be real: it’s no substitute for a lawyer. When it comes to complex legal issues or high-stakes matters, ChatGPT simply falls short. It just can’t match the level of analysis or insight that a lawyer can offer and will likely leave you with incomplete or inadequate legal advice. A good lawyer will provide personalised legal advice and guidance that is specific to your situation. They can help you navigate the legal system, negotiate with other parties, and ensure that your rights are protected every step of the way.

If you’re facing a legal issue, it’s always a good idea to seek out the help of a qualified and experienced lawyer who can provide you with the personalised attention and advice you need. And if you happen to come across ChatGPT in your googling, be sure to take its answers with a grain of salt and double-check any information it gives you.

As a lawyer who loves leveraging the latest technology to enhance my legal practice, I’m excited about the potential of AI language models like ChatGPT to streamline legal research and improve access to legal information. ChatGPT is a relatively new technology and will only improve with time. Therefore, despite its limitations, ChatGPT can still be a useful tool for lawyers. However, I recognise the importance of maintaining a human touch when it comes to legal services. After all, you can’t beat the personalised advice and guidance of a human lawyer who truly cares about your case.

Related news

Rainbow Tick certification

We’re proud to share that Rice Speir has achieved Rainbow Tick certification! The Rainbow Tick is a certification awarded to organisations that have demonstrated their commitment to creating safe, inclusive and welcoming workplaces for the rainbow community. The certification process included informative workshops, a review of internal policies and practices, and an opportunity to reflect…

When road licences go too far

Paper Roads, Public Trusts, and Long‑Term Infrastructure: What Ours Not Mines v Hauraki District Council Means for Local Government The Court of Appeal’s decision in Ours Not Mines Ltd v Hauraki District Council [2026] NZCA 138 is one of the most important local government roading cases in recent years.  Although it arose out of a…

Court strikes out trespass claim against council officers

Council officers often enter private properties to carry out their statutory duties.  The recent decision in Taupō District Council v Paalvast [2026] NZDC 3814 confirms that, provided they follow the correct steps, they can do so lawfully without risking a claim against them in trespass. This is an important decision – and may be relied…

Is the balance shifting in alcohol regulation?

Last week, the Government introduced the Sale and Supply of Alcohol (improving Alcohol Regulation) Amendment Bill (Bill). While much of the commentary has focused on the hospitality sector, the changes will be just as significant for local government and District Licensing Committees (DLCs). What the bill does: Narrows the scope for who can object to…